People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The gyro was amazing! The pizza was pretty good. In all fairness we just got a slice of cheese for my daughter who refuses to eat anything on it. We were starving and every restaurant had a 30 minute wait. We were able to walk in and order right away. The food came out fast and fresh. ”
“ We were heading into Panama for some Italian and the traffic was horrible so my daughter found this place at Pier Park. Didn't know what to expect, but it was a real pleasant surprise. The staff was freindly, prices seemed ok for a tourist trap. Ordered a meat and supreme calzone. Man, there's things were good. Ricotta cheese was creamy and melted, olive oil was nice, plenty of meat and veggies inside. These were definitely not a single person portions. We will be back. ”
“ A great place to get a quick slice .mine just came out out of the oven so it didn't need to be reheated. I recommend waiting like i did. ”
“ I visit family in Panama City and this our place to eat. Went there today during hot busy July 4 weekend. Too many patrons inside to stay cool so we enjoyed a large pizza outside in the shade. The pizza tastes delicious and 'home made'. Looking forward to going there during my next visit! ”
“ Just had the Gyro and calzone OMG this has to be the best place in PCB as far as NY food! You guys know how to make amazing food!!! Definitely coming back just moved to the area! ”
“ Friday night and we were Hungry but not wanting to really dine out again. This was a great place for a quick bite for something really good and fresh. Large portions, of course we over ordered and had to take togo boxes. Located right inside Pier Park with seating inside or out. Super friendly Staff. ”
“ Amazing service and food , very clean and inviting , it was the best Philly cheese steak I have had in years , and my wife loved the pizza she got , the staff were very friendly and accommodating, I definitely recommend them to everyone ”
“ Great fry basket!!! Made Must do and calzone is huge!!! Made fresh to order!!! Great friendly staff and food is amazing!!! These yankee Yorkers really know how to cook!!!! U go boys! Prices reasonable and esp for the quantity of food! Order food while ur kiddos do bungee jump and bumper boats!!! ”
Menu
Hamburger With Fries
US$15.49Red Bull
US$4.5010''
US$12.486 Rolls
US$7.9912 Rolls
US$11.99
About
New York Pizza & Grill
Welcome to New York Pizza & Grill, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Panama City Beach, Florida. Situated at 600 Pier Park Drive, this inviting eatery offers a flavorful escape for both locals and tourists alike. With a reputation for serving freshly made, delicious foods, it's no wonder that patrons find themselves returning time and time again.
From the moment you step inside, the vibrant atmosphere welcomes you. The staff is friendly and eager to ensure you have a memorable dining experience. As a reviewer for Foodjoyy, I can’t help but be charmed by the impressive array of menu options, which skillfully blend classic New York flavors with a touch of Southern hospitality.
Many customers rave about the gyro, describing it as "amazing." Melody Van Etten, one happy diner, said it was one of the best she’s tasted, perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor. The pizza, although a simple cheese slice by request of a picky eater, also garnered praise for its freshness and quick service—just what you need when hunger strikes on a busy day.
Speaking of pizza, the reviews speak highly of the varieties available. Christina D appreciated the "homemade" taste of the large pizza she enjoyed outdoors, emphasizing how the charming setting adds to the experience. Whether you opt for a classic pepperoni, or a unique combination, you're likely to savor every slice.
For those seeking something adventurous, the calzone is a must-try. Chuck Wray could not get enough of the meat and supreme calzone, highlighting its creamy ricotta and generous portions—perfect for those with hearty appetites. Lyubo Lesiv weighed in too, declaring it among the best offerings in PCB when it comes to NY-style food.
The magic at New York Pizza & Grill isn’t just in the food; it's in the swift service, making it a great choice for those busy days at the beach. Ray Dude’s experience exemplified this perfectly—he enjoyed a slice straight out of the oven, relishing the freshness that only a quality pizzeria can deliver.
In summary, New York Pizza & Grill stands out as a top choice for anyone seeking delicious Italian-American comfort food in Panama City Beach. The combination of speedy service, friendly staff, and mouthwatering dishes, from gyros to calzones, guarantees that your visit will be a rewarding culinary experience. Don’t miss out on this wonderful eatery on your next trip!
Book a table